Estate Planning | by Jules Buxbaum | Sunday, January 12, 2025
Estate planning laws matter whether you’ve lived in one state your entire life or you split your time between multiple regions. Estate planning laws can vary widely among New York (NY), North Carolina (NC), and Florida (FL), and overlooking even a small rule could cause big problems for your heirs. For starters, every state imposes its own formalities on wills, trusts, and powers of attorney, so it’s important to review your documents if you’ve moved or acquired property somewhere new. To learn more about state-specific tax considerations that may affect your estate plan, take a look at our state-by-state tax benefits comparison.
Figuring out what documents you need is only half the battle. As your family situation and finances change, so must your estate plan. Below, we’ll explore the distinct legal elements, tax implications, and probate processes you should know before finalizing your documents in NY, NC, or FL.
Unlike some areas of law affected by federal guidelines, estate planning is typically regulated at the state level. This means any detail—such as the required number of witnesses for a will—can differ significantly from one state to another.
For example, New York allows handwritten wills only in very narrow circumstances (like active military duty), whereas Florida generally does not honor them unless they meet specific validation rules. North Carolina, in turn, may recognize an out-of-state will if it was valid in the state where it was originally executed.
By adapting your estate plan to meet each state’s legal standards, you reduce the risk of your will or powers of attorney being questioned—or even invalidated—in court.
New York has some unique requirements that can come as a surprise to newcomers. The state requires two witnesses when executing a will, and these witnesses generally must see you sign. Additionally, New York imposes a state estate tax on larger estates, sometimes referred to as having a “tax cliff” for estates that exceed the exemption by more than 5%.
According to a 2021 study cited by Caring.com, only 32.9% of adults nationwide reported having a will or trust. This figure illustrates how often estate tax planning gets overlooked. Failing to draft valid documents in New York could lead to a lengthy probate process and higher tax liabilities for heirs, especially if an estate crosses the current exemption limit. New York’s exemption is lower than the federal threshold, meaning you could owe state tax even if you avoid federal estate tax.
Another critical difference in New York is the “right of election.” Even if your will omits your spouse or leaves them less than a third of your estate, New York law allows your spouse to claim a minimum share anyway. Individuals who wish to disinherit or minimize a spouse’s portion must consider whether prenuptial or postnuptial agreements are valid under New York law.
North Carolina does not impose a state estate tax, which can simplify certain planning strategies. But the state does have specific will-validation rules, similar to New York’s. You typically need two witnesses, and the will must be signed—either by you or someone at your direction—in all witnesses’ presence.
One advantage unique to North Carolina is the option of “living probate,” which allows you to have your will validated by a court while you are still alive. While not widely used, this process can reduce disputes among heirs by confirming that your will is valid and executed properly before it’s ever needed.
If you moved to North Carolina from another state, you might already have a will. However, an out-of-state document may still require review to confirm that every clause lines up with North Carolina law. Though NC does recognize documents validly signed in your former state, minor differences in phrasing can cause local institutions to ask for additional proof or clarification.
Bright sunshine and no state income tax attract retirees to Florida, but the state also grants unique benefits and imposes strict rules. Florida has no separate estate tax or inheritance tax, so only the federal estate tax could apply to high-net-worth estates. The probate process itself can be less complicated than New York’s if you have a smaller estate, though ancillary probate may still be necessary if you own real property outside Florida.
Florida’s homestead protections can impact how you plan your estate. Real property designated as a homestead is shielded from certain creditors, but at the same time, stringent transfer rules may limit your flexibility. Additionally, Florida law clearly defines how your residence passes to a surviving spouse or minor children, so you should be mindful of these provisions when drafting deeds or trusts.
Florida is one of the few states to permit electronic wills. This makes it possible to draft, sign, and store a will digitally, provided you follow the state’s rules for remote witnesses and notaries. If executed incorrectly, however, electronic wills can be deemed invalid. That’s why careful attention to Florida’s specific rules is essential.
NY, NC, and FL share certain requirements, such as mandating two witnesses for will execution. Yet each state differs in aspects like estate taxes, probate simplicity, and homestead rules. A single estate plan often can cover property in multiple states, but you might face ancillary probate—or even contradictory clauses—if local laws clash with your existing documents.
If you have significant assets in more than one state, consider creating a revocable living trust to bypass probate. Another strategy is to designate transfer-on-death beneficiaries or build out payable-on-death accounts. The method you choose may hinge on each state’s unique legal frameworks.
Tax liability is a frequent concern for people thinking about estate planning. Currently, New York does have a state-level estate tax, while North Carolina and Florida do not. However, all three states remain subject to federal estate tax for individuals whose estates exceed the federal exemption, which is scheduled to drop significantly in 2026 if no new legislation is passed.
If estate tax minimization is a top priority, it’s helpful to know how these states approach the issue. You can read more about state-level estate tax differences in our article on estate taxes in NY, NC, and FL. High-net-worth individuals often pursue trusts or lifetime gifts to reduce the taxed portion of the estate before death.
Across all three states, the main documents in any plan include wills, trusts, financial powers of attorney, and healthcare directives. Each state enforces its own versions of laws around these documents. For example, Florida might call a medical directive a “healthcare surrogate,” while North Carolina uses different terminology entirely.
If you become incapacitated, a durable power of attorney helps someone handle financial matters on your behalf. Shortfalls in your power of attorney—such as lacking the right language for real estate transactions—could delay urgent decisions, especially if the document doesn’t comply with local statutory standards. Always confirm your forms meet each state’s particular requirements.
One popular tool to streamline multi-state property handling is a revocable living trust. You can transfer real estate from each state into the trust, helping you avoid separate probate proceedings. Because you can revoke or change the trust during your lifetime, it’s flexible enough to adapt if you move or acquire new assets.
Estate planning isn’t just about transferring wealth when you pass away. It can also address guardianship for minor children or provide for an adult with special needs. North Carolina, for instance, requires specific language if you intend to grant a guardian broad powers, while Florida’s guardianship statutes may be triggered automatically if you’ve designated no one to oversee an incapacitated adult’s affairs.
NY, NC, and FL all have procedures to appoint guardians for children, but they also treat spousal elections and step-children differently. Review your will or trust carefully to confirm that your chosen guardians and beneficiaries align with state definitions of family—and that your plan accounts for any blended-family dynamics.
From social media profiles to crypto wallets, digital assets need attention. New York and Florida have enacted versions of the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act (RUFADAA), which governs how executors or trustees can access digital property. North Carolina permits digital asset directives as well, but practical access often depends on your account settings and the content of your estate documents.
Retirement planning goes hand-in-hand with estate planning. If you plan to leave substantial assets to heirs or charities, you’ll want to coordinate your distribution preferences with your overall financial strategy. Accounts like IRAs, 401(k)s, or 457 plans fall under federal regulations, yet individual states can still influence how beneficiaries receive or manage these assets.
2Pi Financial encourages a broader perspective: not only do you want the correct legal documents in place, but you also want to optimize your asset mix and risk level based on future earning potential. This driver is important because many people might reduce equity too early, leaving them short in retirement. If you’d like to see how adjusting retirement age, risk factors, or annual savings could improve your plan’s stability, explore our Two Pi Financial Planning Engine. It illustrates how shifting even one variable—like your retirement date—can keep your wealth from running out.
Many folks underestimate the tax consequences for estates in New York, skip witnesses in Florida, or assume North Carolina’s rules are identical to their old state. These errors lead to confusion, unnecessary probate delays, and even legal disputes among heirs.
A particularly frequent misstep is forgetting about beneficiary designations on retirement accounts or life insurance policies. These typically override a will, so always ensure they match your broader plan. Also, if you own an out-of-state vacation home, failing to move it into a trust or hold it in a specific type of joint ownership could trigger a separate probate proceeding (ancillary probate) in that state.
Make sure you understand how your pension or 401(k) passes to survivors. Some states demand spousal consent for beneficiary changes on retirement plans. For an in-depth look at what happens to pensions upon death, see our Estate Planning Guide for Pensions. It’s crucial to confirm that your retirement accounts reflect your preferred heirs, especially if you’ve recently relocated.
Estate planning is an ongoing process that intersects with taxes, real estate laws, and even your approach to saving and investing. If you want broader strategies to preserve wealth or pass on a business, our guide on building a lasting legacy can help you identify next steps. Whether you’re a retiree or a young professional, it’s never too early to set up solid directives and beneficiary designations.
No matter where you live—NY, NC, or FL—making your estate plan airtight requires staying on top of local laws. By reviewing your will, updating powers of attorney as statutes change, and planning around state-specific taxes, you can save your loved ones time and money. Finally, if you’re looking for dynamic approaches to lower estate taxes or protect assets, see our article on advanced estate planning strategies.
Whether you’re just starting your estate plan or revising it for the third time, remember that each state has its own legal nuances. A thorough plan acknowledges those differences while focusing on what truly matters: safeguarding your assets and the people you care about most.
1. Caring.com. (2021). “2021 Wills and Estate Planning Study.” Available at: https://www.caring.com/caregivers/estate-planning/wills-survey
2. KlenkLaw. (2024). “Significant Changes for 2025 That May Affect Your Estate Plan.” Available at: https://www.klenklaw.com/blog/significant-changes-for-2025-that-may-affect-your-estate-plan/
3. LegalZoom. (n.d.). “Estate Planning When You Have Property in Different States.” Available at: https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/estate-planning-when-you-have-property-in-different-states
© 2025 2PiFinancial. All rights reserved
Version: 1.2.9216.31485